LAUSR

PURPOSE Although large-scale randomised clinical trials have established that radiotherapy (RT) - alone or combined with hormonal therapy (HT) - is effective in reducing the risk of ipsilateral breast tumour recurrence (IBTR), overall survival does not seem to be improved by adjuvant therapies. We sought to ascertain whether specific criteria can be adopted to avoid RT with an acceptable rate of IBTR after breast-conserving surgery (BCS) achieving tumour-free margins. PATIENTS AND METHODS This non-randomised prospective study concerned the outcome of patients who underwent BCS for ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) and were prospectively assessed by means of an established scoring system based on width of free margins in association with age <40, presence of comedonecrosis, high grade, ER negativity and HER2 positivity, to orient the use of any adjuvant therapies. RESULTS From March 2000 to April 2006, a total of 224 patients were enrolled and followed up for this study. No adjuvant treatment was considered for 76 patients, while 53, 39 and 56 patients received HT alone, RT alone, and RT plus HT, respectively. After a median follow-up of 129.6 months, 25 patients developed an IBTR, corresponding to a yearly rate of 1.138% (95% CI: 0.769-1.684). CONCLUSION When the criteria considered in the present study were applied to address the use of adjuvant therapies, no RT was administered to 57.6% of patients, 33.9% received no adjuvant treatments at all, and the rate of IBTR was low. Our findings support the conviction that the risk/benefit of omitting RT may lean on the side of the latter in selected patients.