At iScience, we take service to authors very seriously. Our philosophy with respect to the editorial process is that papers should be reviewed for the findings they claim and show,… Click to show full abstract
At iScience, we take service to authors very seriously. Our philosophy with respect to the editorial process is that papers should be reviewed for the findings they claim and show, as opposed to the findings we wish they showed. These are the reasons why we have been, from the beginning, painstakingly parsing referee reports to communicate to authors, for example, which comments are mandatory to address and which are instead fodder for future work.
               
Click one of the above tabs to view related content.