LAUSR.org creates dashboard-style pages of related content for over 1.5 million academic articles. Sign Up to like articles & get recommendations!

For Labor to Build Upon: Wars, Depression, and Pandemic. By William B. GouldIV . New York: Cambridge University Press, 2022. 280p. $89.99 cloth, $29.99 paper.

Photo from wikipedia

(Angie Maxwell, “Why Trump Became a Confederate President,” The Forum, 2021). Some portions ofWhite Nationalism and the Republican Party have parallels to existing treatments of the modern Republican Party, but… Click to show full abstract

(Angie Maxwell, “Why Trump Became a Confederate President,” The Forum, 2021). Some portions ofWhite Nationalism and the Republican Party have parallels to existing treatments of the modern Republican Party, but that does not mean that it is not an original and important contribution. The book’s clear narrative structure and ability to weave in insights from multiple disciplines and (perhaps just as importantly) multiple methodological traditions mean that the synthesis and analysis in this book cannot be found elsewhere. It is also clearly positioned in the tradition of New Political Science. Ehrenberg does not feel constrained by the empiricist’s dispassionate description and causal analysis; his views on Trump and the current Republican Party are clear throughout. Although the book has much to offer, the period being discussed at various points in the narrative can be difficult to ascertain. For example, on p. 4, Ehrenberg argues that the “Republicans have been the nation’s dominant political party for the past 40 years,” but the next page refers to the “Republicans’ fifty year hegemony.” The half-century seems to be the timeframe used most often, but there are examples and roots of today’s modern Republican politics that harken back more than 70 years. It is possible that the author wishes to keep this starting point vague, because identifying “the beginning” of any political movement or idea is a fool’s errand. Nonetheless, consistently identifying the scope of temporal analysis, or at least acknowledging the difficulty of such a task, would serve as a helpful guidepost for readers and scholars who will rely on this work. More substantively, the focus of Republican politics examined in this book is at the federal level, which might leave some readers to wonder whether these same patterns are evident in the states. Even the claim that the Republicans have been the dominant political party for the past 40 years might be a questionable assumption were states and localities a more explicit part of the focus. Particularly in today’s America, where perhaps the most prominent examples of attempts to manipulate the levers of power to gain and maintain minority rule are at the state level, a focus on (or at least a tip of the hat to) state politics and federalism might be helpful. For example, Jake Grumbach’s Laboratories against Democracy (2022) would provide a helpful companion volume for those who wish to explore many of these questions at the state level. The book may also have benefited from a more formal consideration of what constitutes a political party. Revealing all the contours of this debate would be a distraction from the tight structure of this book, but a brief discussion of what the author means when he describes “the Republican Party” might be helpful. Some of this is revealed in the fascinating details of the people and events of the last half-century, but the reader still might be wondering to what degree these trends are being felt at the grassroots of the party or whether they are simply elite-dominated trends. To borrow again from V. O. Key, does white nationalism and the path toward minority rule exist in “the party in the electorate,” the party organization,” the “party in office,” or in all three at once? (Politics, Parties, and Pressure Groups, 1942). In the end,White Nationalism and The Republican Party makes a welcome addition to the rapidly growing shelf of books on what Trump’s presidency means for the future of the Republican Party and democracy in America. It should also be read by scholars of political parties and the presidency, particularly those in the New Political Science tradition.

Keywords: party; republican party; build upon; political party; book; labor build

Journal Title: Perspectives on Politics
Year Published: 2023

Link to full text (if available)


Share on Social Media:                               Sign Up to like & get
recommendations!

Related content

More Information              News              Social Media              Video              Recommended



                Click one of the above tabs to view related content.