National Institute of Clinical Excellence guideline (NICE, CG95) recommends CTCA as a 1st line diagnostic test for evaluation of ambulatory patients with suspected stable angina based on its high sensitivity… Click to show full abstract
National Institute of Clinical Excellence guideline (NICE, CG95) recommends CTCA as a 1st line diagnostic test for evaluation of ambulatory patients with suspected stable angina based on its high sensitivity and low cost. This has led to increasing demand for CTCA across the National Health Service (NHS) in order to comply with the NICE recommendation. We studied the utility and effectiveness of CTCA in the evaluation of ambulatory patients with suspected stable angina attending rapid access chest pain clinic (RACPC) in a large tertiary hospital in the UK. The study included consecutive patients attending RACPC over a pre-specified period of 6-months who were suspected of having stable angina and hence, referred for CTCA. The data were collected on demographics, CTCA results including incidental finding and downstream investigations. All patients had a minimum of 12-months follow up for clinical outcomes. A total of 170 patients were referred for CTCA (mean age = 56.8 years, male = 53.5%) out of the 388 consecutive patients who were reviewed in the RACPC during the 6-month period. CTCA was non-diagnostic in 48/170 (28.2%) cases (Breathing artefact 35%, Severe Coronary Calcification 31%, Elevated heart rate/Ectopy 30%) while 63/170 (37.1%) of patients had incidental extra-cardiac findings. Amongst patients with incidental findings, 17/63 (27.0%) underwent further investigations. A total of 54/170 (31.7%) of patients were recommended to have downstream cardiac investigations such as a stress test (DSE/MRI/MPS) (23/170, 15.8%) while 31/170 (18.2%) were referred for invasive coronary angiography. Revascularisation procedures (PCI n=7.6%, CABG n=4.7%) were required in 21/170 (12.4%) patients. Based on 2017 NHS tariffs, overall average cost-per-patient with the initial CTCA approach was £122.11 excluding downstream investigations and £548.43 including the cost of downstream cardiac investigations. Incidental Findings after CTCA Our study suggests that a CTCA based approach is associated with non-diagnostic information in at least 1:4 patients and incidental extracardiac findings in 1:3 patients. Further downstream cardiac investigations are required in around 1:3 patients after a CTCA carried out for evaluation suspected stable angina. The NICE recommendation is based on the low initial cost of CTCA and high sensitivity, however, taking in to account the additional cost of downstream investigations, the average cost per patient of this approach is significantly (4.5 times) higher. None
               
Click one of the above tabs to view related content.