The 10-minute and 3-minute versions of the Psychomotor Vigilance Test (PVT10 and PVT3) and the Karolinska Sleepiness Scale (KSS) are commonly used to assess objective behavioral attention deficits and subjective… Click to show full abstract
The 10-minute and 3-minute versions of the Psychomotor Vigilance Test (PVT10 and PVT3) and the Karolinska Sleepiness Scale (KSS) are commonly used to assess objective behavioral attention deficits and subjective sleepiness in response to sleep loss, respectively. However, the precise time course of relationships between behavioral attention and subjective sleepiness across sleep loss and recovery remains unknown but is critical for determining whether objective and subjective measures track each other. Repeated measures correlation (rmcorr) examined within-individual association between these measures throughout a highly controlled sleep deprivation study. Forty-one healthy adults (ages 21-49;mean±SD, 33.9±8.9y;18 females) participated in a 13-night experiment consisting of two baseline nights (10h-12h time-in-bed, TIB) followed by 5 sleep restriction (SR) nights (4h TIB), 4 recovery nights (12h TIB), and 36h total sleep deprivation (TSD). A neurobehavioral test battery, including the PVT10, PVT3, and KSS, was administered every 2h during wakefulness. Rmcorr compared PVT10 [lapses (reaction time [RT] >500ms) and 1/RT (response speed)], PVT3 (lapses [RT>355ms], 1/RT), and KSS scores by examining correlations by day (e.g., Baseline day 2) and time point (e.g., 1000h-2000h). Rmcorr ranges: r=0.1:small; r=0.3:moderate; r=0.5:large. Generally, the correlations between the PVT10 and KSS and the PVT3 and KSS showed a similar pattern for lapses and 1/RT. PVT lapses and KSS scores showed small or non-significant correlations during baseline and recovery, whereas SR and TSD showed moderate correlations. PVT 1/RT and KSS scores showed moderate correlations during baseline, moderate to large correlations during SR and TSD, but small correlations during recovery. PVT10 and PVT3 1/RT showed stronger correlations with KSS scores than lapses. Additionally, all relationships showed moderate to large correlations by time point across the study. Overall, the relationship between behavioral attention and sleepiness was stronger across sleep loss (SR or TSD) relative to fully rested states while it was consistently relatively strong at specific times of day throughout the study. In contrast to published literature, there is a remarkably stable relationship between an individual’s objective behavioral attention performance and perceptions of sleepiness during sleep loss, which is not evident during recovery or at baseline. ONR Award No. N00014-11-1-0361;NIH UL1TR000003;NASA NNX14AN49G and 80NSSC20K0243;NIH R01DK117488
               
Click one of the above tabs to view related content.