Individuals with insomnia often show subjective-objective sleep discrepancy, especially an overestimation of their sleep onset latency (SOL) while the factors associated with such discrepancy remained unclear. Whilst cognitive behavioral therapy… Click to show full abstract
Individuals with insomnia often show subjective-objective sleep discrepancy, especially an overestimation of their sleep onset latency (SOL) while the factors associated with such discrepancy remained unclear. Whilst cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) has been recommend as the first-line treatment for insomnia, there has been limited research to investigate the effects of CBT-I on sleep onset perception in youths with insomnia. The present study aimed to identify potential variables related to sleep onset misperception and explore the effects of CBT-I on sleep onset misperception among youths with insomnia. Sixty treatment-seeking youths with insomnia (mean: 19.74 ±2.42, female: 55%) were recruited to assess for their sleep and clinical characteristics using self-report questionnaires and 7-days sleep diary and actigraphy (T1). A subset of the sample (N=19) further completed an 8-week CBT-I programme and assessed at one-week post-treatment (T2) and 6-month follow-up (T3). Sleep misperception index was computed by subtracting actigraphy-measured SOL from sleep diary reported SOL, where a higher value indicates a higher degree of SOL overestimation. Demographic, clinical and sleep-related variables were compared between high versus low sleep onset misperception groups as divided by the mean of the sample. Changes in sleep onset misperception after CBT-I were analyzed using repeated measures ANOVA. High sleep onset misperception group demonstrated a significantly higher degree of anxiety symptoms (t(28)=-3.92, p<.01) and pre-sleep cognitive arousal (t(28)=-0.49, p<.05) as compared to low sleep onset misperception group. Participants who completed CBT-I showed a significant decrease in subjective-objective SOL discrepancy (T1=19.52, T2=6.96, T3=-1.37). A post-hoc pairwise comparison using the Bonferroni correction suggested a significant decrease in subjective-objective SOL discrepancy from T1 to T3 (p<.05). Significant improvement in pre-sleep cognitive arousal was found from T1 to T3 (<.001) and such an improvement was found to be significantly correlated with the reduction in sleep onset misperception (r=0.16, p<.05). Sleep onset misperception is associated with anxiety symptoms and pre-sleep cognitive arousal in youths with insomnia. Preliminary evidence supports that CBT-I is effective in improving sleep onset misperception in youths with insomnia. Future research should explore the neurophysiological mechanism underlying sleep onset misperception and the changes of such a discrepancy upon intervention.
               
Click one of the above tabs to view related content.