LAUSR

We thank Dr Mohner for his letter to the editor on our recent report on the acceptable risk (AR) and maximum tolerable risk (MTR) of dying from lung cancer due to diesel motor exhaust (DME). Our calculations, which included alternative risk estimates based on reanalyses by us and others, indicated that an acceptable excess risk of lung cancer mortality can only be achieved at very low DME exposure levels. This suggests that diesel engines using older technologies should be removed from the workplace when possible or emissions strictly controlled. Dr Mohner argues in his letter that the derived exposure limits were too conservative. The first argument is based on a recent review by Dr Mohner and Wendt in Critical Reviews in Toxicology where they conclude that there are methodological issues with the three studies …