LAUSR

Chlorine (Cl2) is a chemical widely used in industry, in cleaning products, and as a germicide in swimming pools. Acute exposure to high levels of Cl2 gas in industrial accidents can cause severe airway injury and/or life-threatening acute lung injury, whereas lowerlevel exposures may result in chronic airway inflammation and airflow obstruction (1). Examples of the latter include reactive airway dysfunction syndrome in women exposed to Cl2 released by a chemical mixture used for household cleaning (2) and highly prevalent bronchial hyperreactivity in competitive swimmers who train in chlorinated indoor pools (3). Notably, bronchial biopsy specimens in such swimmers demonstrate airway inflammation and remodeling similar to that shown in asthma (4). The mechanism by which Cl2 gas injures the airway involves oxidants, including hypochlorous acid generated from Cl2 in aqueous solution. This is supported by observations that antioxidants mitigate lung injury and airway hyperresponsiveness (AHR) in Cl2 gas–exposed rats (5) and mice (6). Neutrophils play a critical role, as blocking Cl2-induced neutrophilic infiltration of the airways abrogated AHR in Cl2-exposed mice (7). The cysteinyl leukotrienes (LTs), LTC4, LTD4, and LTE4, are also important, as exposure to Cl2 gas triggers release of these lipid mediators in the lungs of mice (8), and blockade of the cysLT1 receptor reduced Cl2induced airway inflammation and AHR (9). Cysteinyl LTs are metabolites of arachidonic acid, which is deesterified from phospholipids by phospholipase A2 and metabolized to bioactive eicosanoid metabolites via cyclooxygenase or lipoxygenase pathways. Synthesis of LTs requires 5-lipoxygenase (5-LO), expression of which is largely restricted to cells of myeloid origin. The product of 5-LO action on arachidonic acid is LTA4, an unstable epoxide intermediate that is further metabolized by LTC4 synthase to LTC4 or by LTA4 hydrolase to LTB4. LTC4 and its peptidase-derived metabolites, LTD4 and LTE4, collectively signal via cysLT1 and cysLT2 receptors to produce bronchoconstriction, mucus cell hyperplasia, airway smooth-muscle thickening, and subepithelial fibrosis (10), bioactivities highly relevant to Cl2 gas–induced airway injury. The dependence of Cl2-induced AHR in mice on both neutrophils and cysteinyl LTs poses an apparent conundrum, as neutrophils are alone among myeloid cells in not expressing LTC4 synthase. In this issue of the Journal, McGovern and colleagues (pp. 681–689) address this problem in their work presented (11). As in their previous studies, the authors exposed mice to Cl2 gas at 100 or 400 parts per million for 5 minutes, which elicited influx to the lungs of large numbers of inflammatory cells and release of cysteinyl LTs into BAL fluid. To determine the cellular source of the cysteinyl LTs, they selectively depleted each of the major inflammatory cell types recruited to the lungs after Cl2 exposure. Macrophages were depleted by three different strategies, instillation of clodronate liposomes, diphtheria toxin administration to CD11cDTR mice, and use of CCR2 mice, each resulting in an z50% decrease in BAL macrophages after Cl2 exposure but resulting in no reduction in cysteinyl LTs. Likewise, depletion of eosinophils with an anti–IL-5 antibody had no effect on lung cysteinyl LT levels. On the other hand, treatment with an antibody to Ly6G, which blocked neutrophil influx (without decreasing macrophages), fully abrogated the Cl2-induced release of cysteinyl LTs. Because neutrophils are incapable of synthesizing cysteinyl LTs, the authors considered the possibility that they cooperate with other cells in producing these mediators. Thus, they cocultured mouse neutrophils and tracheal epithelial cells and found that these cocultures produced significant quantities of cysteinyl LTs, whereas neither cell type did so alone. Furthermore, when neutrophils from 5-LO–knockout mice were cultured with wild-type tracheal epithelial cells, no increase in cysteinyl LT synthesis occurred. The implication is that 5-LO–expressing neutrophils synthesize LTA4, which they then transfer to LTC4 synthase–expressing epithelial cells for conversion to cysteinyl LTs. The authors propose this as the mechanism by which cysteinyl LTs are produced in the lung after exposure to Cl2 gas. Transcellular biosynthesis of eicosanoids is a well-recognized phenomenon, and synthesis of LTC4 from LTA4 released by neutrophils, then taken up by other cells expressing LTC4 synthase, has been reported previously (12). McGovern and colleagues (11) expand these observations by demonstrating that neutrophils participate with tracheal epithelial cells in the formation of cysteinyl LTs. Although the finding that this occurs in vitro does not establish that neutrophil–airway epithelial cell transcellular LTC4 biosynthesis accounts for production of cysteinyl LTs in the lungs of Cl2-exposed mice, this mechanism appears highly plausible. Furthermore, it reconciles the dependence of Cl2-induced AHR both on neutrophils, which lack LTC4 synthase, and on cysteinyl LTs. A larger point to be drawn from the study is that even when controlled experiments in a well-defined animal model pinpoint a specific cell type as essential to a particular disease outcome, the cell type in question likely drives pathophysiology in concert with other cells. In the case of Cl2induced alterations in airway physiology, neutrophils are clearly essential, but they do not act alone. The current study raises multiple questions for further investigation. What are the Cl2-induced chemokines or other signals that elicit neutrophil influx to the lung? Besides airway epithelial