LAUSR.org creates dashboard-style pages of related content for over 1.5 million academic articles. Sign Up to like articles & get recommendations!

Flat Rock of the Old Time: Letters from the Mountains to the Lowcountry, 1837–1939 ed. by Robert B. Cuthbert (review)

Photo by philldane from unsplash

allotment policies led to Helen Hunt Jackson’s A Century of Dishonor (Boston, 1881) and Alice Cunningham Fletcher’s various works—books that remain well known, admittedly only among historians and primarily for… Click to show full abstract

allotment policies led to Helen Hunt Jackson’s A Century of Dishonor (Boston, 1881) and Alice Cunningham Fletcher’s various works—books that remain well known, admittedly only among historians and primarily for their impact on public policy. Jackson and Fletcher grounded their books in documents and public records, a practice eventually embraced by male scholars. Yet their commitment to racial theories about culture and their association with forced acculturation policies, which gradually lost favor, led to their eventual dismissal “as biased or ‘sentimental’ by professional historians” (p. 50). The academic professionalization of history further erodedwomen’s scholarly and political status. Men controlled universities, and although some accepted women graduate students, they ensured that all doors to university academic employment remained closed to women upon graduation. Women’s colleges, high schools, state historical societies, or museums, they argued, were the only suitable places for women. Further, Frederick Jackson Turner’s impact on the field focused scholarly attention on the supposedly inevitable progress of the Euro-American frontier. Indians were a relatively inconsequential topic.Women, then, opportunistically turned to Native American history precisely because “it was the only subject not claimed by their male colleagues” (p. 106). Rhea provides a meaty discussion of the handful of women professionally trained in the first decades of the twentieth century, including Emma Helen Blair, Louise Phelps Kellogg, and Annie Heloise Abel. He also highlights several indigenous scholars—Rachel Caroline Eaton, Anna Lazola Lewis, and Muriel Hazel Wright—who urged others to incorporate indigenous perspectives into their work. The volume concludes with the indomitable Angie Debo, the best known of them all. These women, he argues, embraced the field as a way to participate in the profession, to strive for scholarly visibility, and to challenge gender prejudice in the academy. They did not share the preprofessional women’s goal of national prestige and political power. Nor did they always agree with, or get along with, one another. Historiography is, unfortunately, something of a hard sell to the general reader. This book will be of greatest interest to historians, particularly specialists in Native American and gender studies. I wish my former professor was still around to read it. Perhaps he would recognize his own implication in a system that restricted people’s access to scholarly endeavors based on gender and then undermined their efforts to carve out a place for themselves within the profession. Happily, over the last forty years, things have changed considerably for the field of Native American history and for women historians. Rhea’s welcome work acknowledges those who paved the way.

Keywords: rock old; time letters; old time; history; flat rock; native american

Journal Title: Journal of Southern History
Year Published: 2017

Link to full text (if available)


Share on Social Media:                               Sign Up to like & get
recommendations!

Related content

More Information              News              Social Media              Video              Recommended



                Click one of the above tabs to view related content.